Legal
False Self-Employment in the Netherlands 2026: DBA Enforcement Guide for Freelancers & Expats
If you're freelancing in the Netherlands as a ZZP'er or expat contractor, this affects you directly. From January 1, 2026, the Dutch Tax Authority (Belastingdienst) fully enforces rules on false self-employment (schijnzelfstandigheid). No more warnings, no more leniency. Fines, back-assessments, and penalty surcharges are now a reality. In this guide we explain what has changed, what the consequences are, and what you must concretely do to continue working safely in the Dutch market. Also check our guide on safe freelancer contracts.
What Is False Self-Employment?
False self-employment (schijnzelfstandigheid) means you work as a freelancer on paper, but in practice you function as an employee. This is a crucial concept for anyone freelancing in the Netherlands — whether you're Dutch-born or an expat who registered at the KVK (Chamber of Commerce). The Dutch Tax Authority does not look at your contract, but at the actual working relationship. Is there an authority relationship? Do you only work for this one client? Does the client determine when and how you work? Then you may be classified as falsely self-employed.
Under Dutch law (Burgerlijk Wetboek, article 7:610), an employment contract exists when three elements are present: labor (arbeid), wages (loon), and an authority relationship (gezagsverhouding). If your freelance arrangement meets all three — regardless of your nationality or how long you've been in the Netherlands — you have a problem. Understanding the difference between ZZP and BV is also relevant here.
Timeline: From VAR to Full Enforcement
Before 2016
VAR declaration
Indemnification for clients, no audits on employment relationships
2016
DBA Act replaces VAR
Model agreements introduced to assess working relationships
2016-2024
Enforcement moratorium
Only action against malicious intent, no fines for good faith situations
Jan 1, 2025
End of moratorium
Start of enforcement with "soft landing" transition period
2025
Transition year
Company visits, no fines, leniency for first violations
Jan 1, 2026
Full enforcement
Fines and back-assessments can be imposed directly
Jun 1, 2026
Model agreement "no employer authority" expires
This widely-used model agreement will no longer be valid
Mar 6, 2026
VBAR clarification part scrapped
Minister Aartsen scraps VBAR clarification due to market unrest. Zelfstandigenwet announced as replacement.
Aug 31, 2026
Rechtsvermoeden deadline
Legal presumption (€38/hour) must be published in the Staatsblad
2027+
Self-Employment Act expected
New law replacing VBAR clarification part. Timeline uncertain, delays likely.
2029
All old model agreements expire
No more model agreements as protection
What Changed on January 1, 2026?
The transition year of 2025 is definitively over. State Secretary Heijnen refused to extend the soft landing, despite a motion from the House of Representatives (Tweede Kamer). For expats and international freelancers who may have relied on the relaxed enforcement of previous years, this is a critical shift.
That said, the enforcement approach is not purely punitive.
The 9 Criteria: How Does the Tax Authority Assess Your Situation?
The Dutch Supreme Court's (Hoge Raad) Deliveroo ruling (March 2023) and Uber ruling (February 2025) established nine criteria for assessing whether a working relationship qualifies as employment. The Tax Authority now uses these criteria in its enforcement. These apply equally to Dutch and international freelancers — your nationality doesn't matter, only how you work.
| # | Criterion | What the Tax Authority examines |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nature and duration of work | Is it a defined project or ongoing work? |
| 2 | Control over work and hours | Who determines how, when, and where you work? |
| 3 | Integration in the organization | Is your work part of the core activities? |
| 4 | Personal work obligation | Must you perform the work yourself? |
| 5 | How the relationship was established | Application process or business acquisition? |
| 6 | Payment structure | Fixed monthly amount or per project/result? |
| 7 | Commercial risk | Do you bear financial risk? |
| 8 | External entrepreneurship | Multiple clients, own website, investments? |
| 9 | Number of clients and assignment duration | Working long-term for a single client? |
Red and Green Flags
Use these indicators to quickly assess your own situation. Whether you're a Dutch freelancer or an expat working as a ZZP'er, the more green flags that apply to you, the safer your position.
Red flags
- • Fixed working hours (9-5) imposed by client
- • Mandatory presence at the office
- • Direct management by a supervisor
- • Only one client (for years)
- • Working with client's equipment and materials
- • Fixed monthly payment regardless of result
- • Doing the same work as the client's employees
- • Replacing a departed employee
- • Managing the client's personnel
- • Returning as freelancer right after being fired
Green flags
- • Free scheduling: you decide when and where you work
- • Result obligation: you deliver a final product, not hours
- • Multiple clients (3+ per year)
- • Own working methods, approaches and tools
- • Own laptop, software and equipment
- • Market-rate pricing (well above €38/hour)
- • Own website, marketing and acquisition
- • Chamber of Commerce registration and professional appearance
- • Entrepreneurial risk: you bear costs for errors
- • Ability to outsource work to third parties
Consequences: What Happens If You Are Falsely Self-Employed?
Consequences for the freelancer (ZZP'er)
| Consequence | What it means |
|---|---|
| Loss of tax benefits | Self-employed deduction (€1,200), SME profit exemption and starter deduction lapse retroactively |
| Back-assessment | Repayment of wrongly claimed deductions |
| Social security contributions | Employee insurance premiums should have been paid |
| Right to employment contract | You can claim an employment contract with the client |
| Pension | Possible right to participate in client's pension fund |
Consequences for the client (opdrachtgever)
| Consequence | What it means |
|---|---|
| Payroll tax back-assessment | All payroll taxes and premiums must still be paid |
| Penalty surcharge | 10-100% of back-assessment in case of intent or gross negligence |
| Pension obligations | Possible retroactive pension accrual |
| Extended retroactive effect | In case of malicious intent, also for periods before Jan 1, 2025 |
New Legislation: From VBAR to Self-Employment Act
The Dutch government has been trying to clarify freelancer rules for years. The original VBAR (Wet Verduidelijking Beoordeling Arbeidsrelaties) was meant to codify when someone is an employee vs. a freelancer. However, on March 6, 2026, Minister Aartsen announced that the cabinet is scrapping the clarification part of the VBAR because it caused too much unrest among freelancers and clients. For expats: this is a significant shift in the legal landscape.
In its place, the cabinet is developing the Zelfstandigenwet (Self-Employment Act), a coalition agreement commitment. This new law will provide clearer rules and legal recognition for genuine freelancers. The timeline is 2027 at the earliest. Meanwhile, the rechtsvermoeden (legal presumption) at €38/hour has been detached as separate legislation and must be published in the Staatsblad by August 31, 2026. The Zelfstandigenwet will include two key tests:
Self-employment test
Do you truly bear entrepreneurial risk? Do you invest in your business, have multiple clients, and carry financial risk?
Proves real entrepreneurship
Employment relationship test
Do you determine how and when you work? Is there no authority relationship with your client?
Proves independence
Action Plan: 7 Steps for Every Freelancer
Your action plan for 2026:
- 1Assess your current situation
Use the Tax Authority's online assessment tool (available in English on Business.gov.nl) and review the 9 criteria against your own working relationship. If you're an expat, consider getting a Dutch tax advisor who speaks English.
- 2Work for multiple clients
Aim for at least 3 clients per year. Read our guide on finding clients as a freelancer.
- 3Demonstrate your entrepreneurship
Invest in your own equipment, website, and actively acquire clients. Build a professional brand identity.
- 4Check your rate
Are you earning less than \u20AC38/hour? Use our hourly rate calculator to determine your ideal rate.
- 5Get your administration in order
Written quotes, invoices per project instead of monthly. Use our invoice generator for professional invoices.
- 6Avoid the classic mistakes
Wait at least 6 months after termination before returning as freelancer. Don't manage the client's personnel. Don't accept fixed schedules.
- 7Prepare for the Self-Employment Act
Demonstrate real entrepreneurship now. This will be the standard of the future. Consider whether your legal structure (ZZP vs BV) is still appropriate.
Self-Assessment Checklist: Are You Genuinely Self-Employed?
The 14-point self-employment check
10+ checkmarks? You are probably safe.
7-9 checkmarks? Improve your position on the missing points.
< 7 checkmarks? High risk. Seek professional advice immediately!
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I receive a fine as a freelancer?
Not directly. The penalty surcharge (vergrijpboete) is imposed on the client, not the freelancer. However, as a freelancer you can face back-assessments: you may have to repay the self-employed deduction, the SME profit exemption, and the starter deduction retroactively. Additionally, social security contributions may be claimed retroactively. Use our tax calculator to understand how much these deductions save you.
I've been working for the same client for years. Should I stop?
Not necessarily, but long-term single-client work is a significant risk factor. You should urgently diversify by taking on additional clients. Also ensure other factors clearly demonstrate your entrepreneurship: use your own equipment, set your own hours, bear financial risk, and work on clearly defined projects rather than ongoing duties.
Does setting up a BV (private limited company) help?
A BV does not automatically protect against false self-employment. The Tax Authority looks at the actual working relationship, not the legal form. If the director-major shareholder (DGA) works as a disguised employee, the same rules apply. However, a BV can help demonstrate entrepreneurship in certain cases. Read more in our ZZP vs BV comparison.
What if my rate is below €38/hour?
The rechtsvermoeden (legal presumption) at €38/hour has been detached from the VBAR and is now separate legislation, to be published by August 31, 2026. Below this rate, you are presumed to be an employee unless the client proves otherwise. Earlier proposals discussed a lower threshold of €28/hour, but the current bill maintains €38/hour. Use our hourly rate calculator to determine a proper rate.
Does enforcement also apply to the period before 2025?
For periods before January 1, 2025, the Tax Authority can only impose back-assessments in cases of malicious intent or when previous instructions were ignored. The full enforcement power applies to periods from January 1, 2025 onwards.
When will the Self-Employment Act come into effect?
On March 6, 2026, Minister Aartsen scrapped the clarification part of the VBAR due to market unrest. The Zelfstandigenwet is being developed as a coalition agreement commitment, expected 2027 at the earliest. Meanwhile, the rechtsvermoeden (€38/hour) must be published by August 31, 2026 as separate legislation.
Does a model agreement still offer protection?
Limited protection. Existing approved model agreements remain valid until 2029 at the latest (the "no employer authority" model expires June 1, 2026). However, a model agreement no longer guarantees protection. The Tax Authority looks at the actual working relationship. If reality doesn't match the agreement, enforcement follows regardless.
Related Articles
ZZP Contracts: Avoid False Self-Employment
Safe contracts, model agreements, and essential clauses
ZZP vs BV: Which Legal Structure?
Compare sole proprietorship and private limited company
Essential Insurance for Freelancers
Protect your business and income
Pension for Freelancers
Build your retirement as a self-employed professional
Calculate Your Hourly Rate 2026
Determine the right rate for your freelance work
Tax Changes ZZP 2026
New tax brackets, reduced deductions, and what it means for you
Conclusion
The bottom line? Focus on building genuine entrepreneurship — it's your best protection.